NEWS

A favourable judgement – lost profits

14.07.2019 | EN, News EN, Wojciech Gierszewski EN

NEWS

A favourable judgement – lost profits

lip 14, 2019

We are pleased to announce that in one of the cases conducted by us a final judgement of a Court of Appeal was issued, in which nearly 300.000,00 PLN was adjudicated in favour of our Client, together with interests due to an act of unfair competition.

Our Client sought compensation in a form of lost profits, which he did not obtain as a result of the competitor’s action. In the Polish judicial reality, it is difficult to pursue such claims – i.e. hypothetical amounts, which could have been acquired, had it not been for the infringing party. Judges tend to take a prudent position and, unless evidence demonstrates almost certainty of gaining a certain profit, it is difficult to convince the court to one’s reasons. Obviously, it is very difficult to obtain such evidence of the lost profit, deriving from hypothetical circumstances.

The judgement proves openness of the court and understanding of a real harm that infringing action (in this case – blocking sales) of a market competitor may cause.

This case was also interesting, as it concerned two legal regimes – unfair competition and industrial property law. The defendant, acting to prevent our Client from selling his products was formally entitled to an industrial design. However, he obtained his right in violation of the law, not to protect his rights (which he never had), but to block our Client from launching competitive products.

The Court’s ruling confirms once again the independence and – in some matters – superiority of the law on unfair competition over the industrial property rights. The registration of the industrial design itself does not legitimize the action of a dishonest entrepreneur.  The court stated in the matter that obtaining and exercising a right to an industrial design was unlawful and constituted an act of unfair competition.

See more:

Long awaited AI Act enacted by the European Parliament

The enactment of the AI ACT On 13 March 2024, the European Parliament passed the Artificial Intelligence Act (the so-called AI Act), which has long been a significant focus of attention for many technology companies. A large majority of MEPs voted in favour of the AI...

IP Telegram: Puma’s Community design invalidated

Our new IP Telegram concerns the EU General Court’s decision on Community design belonging to a famous shoe company. Recently, the General Court dismissed the action of Puma whose design was previously invalidated by the EUIPO. What makes this case more interesting...

Contact

We invite you to contact us

Warsaw

Sobieszyńska St., no. 35
00-764 Warsaw
tel. +48 664 948 372

Contact form

7 + 15 =

Contact

We invite you to contact us

Warsaw

Sobieszyńska St., no. 35
00-764 Warsaw
tel. +48 664 948 372

Contact form

7 + 4 =